America’s adversaries revelled and allies shook their heads in dismay at the assault on the heart of U.S. democracy on Wednesday. Many foreign leaders noted the United States’ centuries-long role as a bastion of self-rule by a free population. Some suggested that vaunted position had been diminished and urged a rapid return to it, and several placed the blame for the chaos squarely on President Donald Trump.
Russia and Iran offered predictable ridicule of U.S. democracy – a theme both countries have fallen back on for years, but damning commentary from close allies in Europe showed there was real shock among America’s global partners at the level of bitter division within the country, and the driving force many see behind it.
Below is a sample of the commentary from world leaders, senior diplomats, and state-run media outlets, which will be updated:
“We believe that the American people want safety and tranquillity, especially in the severe situation of the current epidemic, we also hope that the American people can enjoy peace, stability and security as soon as possible,” said Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesperson Hua Chunying.
An editorial column posted by China’s state-run foreign news outlet CGTN on Thursday gloated on behalf of the Communist Party, blaming not just Mr. Trump, but the entire American political system and both parties that lead it for the unrest.
U.S. politicians’ “neverending campaigning seems to have turned them into soundbite-making machines who forget their actual job descriptions (sic) is to solve problems, not keeping their position in Washington at the expense of everybody outside of it,” CGTN charged.
Coming from a country where free speech is an unknown luxury and dissent is quashed, quickly, by force, the rebuke may ring hollow in the West. But America’s most potent adversary will no doubt seize the opportunity in the days ahead to remind its own population of more than 1 billion of the inherent pitfalls of rule by popular mandate.
“Disgraceful scenes in US Congress,” British Prime Minister Boris Johnson, who Mr. Trump once branded Britain’s own “Trump” for his similarly irreverent style and appeal to populist sentiments.
“The United States stands for democracy around the world and it is now vital that there should be a peaceful and orderly transfer of power,” Johnson said.
“What we saw in the United States last night showed the failure and frailty of Western democracy in the world,” Iranian President Hassan Rouhani said Thursday in his first remarks on the assault on Capitol Hill.
“The spread of populism in the United States and the arrival of someone like Trump to power created great problems for America and the world, especially in the Middle East.”
Chancellor Angela Merkel said the images from Capitol Hill made her “angry” and “sad.” She voiced “regret” that Mr. Trump had refused (until a statement issued later, early Thursday morning by the White House) to in any way accepted his election defeat.
But she added that she was “sure U.S. democracy is stronger” than the challenge posed by the rioters at the Capitol, and voiced hope that with the incoming administration of President-elect Joe Biden and his vice president Kamala Harris, a “new chapter of U.S. democracy” would begin in two weeks.
German Foreign Minister Heiko Maas noted that democracy’s enemies would be cheered by the violence at the Capitol, which he accused Mr. Trump of fueling.
“Trump and his supporters must accept the decision of American voters at last and stop trampling on democracy,” Maas said in a tweet.
There was a muted reaction from Moscow overnight, which U.S. security agencies have accused of fomenting the division in American society for years. The initial commentary came from Russia’s Deputy Ambassador to the United Nations, and it could be characterized as smug, at best.
“Quite Maidan-style pictures are coming from DC,” ambassador Dmitry Polyanskiy said on Twitter, referring to 2014 protests in Ukraine that toppled Russian-backed President Viktor Yanukovich. “Some of my friends ask whether someone will distribute crackers to the protesters to echo Victoria Nuland stunt,” he mocked, citing a 2013 visit to Ukraine when then-U.S. Assistant Secretary of State Victoria Nuland offered food to those who had taken to the streets demanding the pro-Kremlin president step down.
Foreign Minister Simon Coveney called the scenes in Washington “a deliberate assault on Democracy by a sitting President & his supporters, attempting to overturn a free & fair election,” in a tweet.
“The world is watching! We hope for restoration of calm,” he said.
“We are hoping for a peaceful transfer of power,” said Chief Cabinet Secretary Katsunobu Kato.
“We decline to comment on President Trump’s political style as this is about U.S. domestic affairs,” he added. “But we hope to see democracy in the United States overcome this difficult situation, calmness and harmony regained, and a peaceful and democratic transfer of power.”
“What happened today in Washington DC is not American,” French President Emmanuel Macron said in a video message posted on Twitter.
“We believe in the strength of our democracies. We believe in the strength of American democracy,” he said, speaking in English.
Prime Minister of Benjamin Netanyahu denounced as “disgraceful” what he called a “rampage” at the U.S. Capitol.
“I have no doubt that American democracy will prevail,” he added.
Netanyahu has been one of President Trump’s most steadfast global allies, and has seen his own political standing boosted significantly by Mr. Trump’s policies in the Middle East, which have diverged sharply from decades of U.S. norms in the tumultuous region. Most notably, Mr. Trump unilaterally recognized Jerusalem — a holy city claimed for decades as a capital both by Jewish Israelis and Palestinians — as the capital of Israel, and he moved the U.S. Embassy to it.
Netanyahu spoke on Thursday just ahead of a meeting with visiting U.S. Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin.
Speaker of the National Assembly Mustafa Sentop said his country had followed the events in Washington “with concern” and he urged calmness.
“We believe that problems will always be solved within law and democracy. As Turkey, we have always been in favor of the law and democracy and we recommend it to everyone,” he said in a tweet.
Prime Minister Scott Morrison, a conservative who has maintained good ties with the Trump administration, described the scenes in Washington as “distressing,” but noted Mr. Trump’s eventual call for his backers at the Capitol to leave.
“We condemn these acts of violence and look forward to a peaceful transfer of Government to the newly elected administration in the great American democratic tradition,” he said on Twitter.
“I think what we’ve seen in the United States is terribly distressing, terribly concerning, and I noted the president’s message this morning to tell people to go home peacefully,” Morrison told reporters on Thursday. “I hope that’s what people are doing and this is a very distressing time in the United States and I feel terribly for what’s happening there.”
“This is one of the world’s greatest democracies, and it remains so because of its forbearance and its persistence in the principles and values upon which the nation was established and I have no doubt that that will prevail.”
“American democratic institutions are strong and hopefully everything will return to normal shortly,” Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said during a radio interview.
Prime Minister Stefan Lofven, in a tweet, described the scenes as “an attack on democracy.”
“President Trump and many members of Congress bear significant responsibility for what’s now taking place,” he said late Wednesday night. “The democratic process of electing a president must be respected.”
“This is an unacceptable attack on the U.S. democracy,” Prime Minster Erna Solberg posted on Twitter. “President Trump is responsible for stopping this. Scary images, and unbelievable that this is happening in the United States.”
U.N. Secretary-General Antonio Guterres was “saddened” by the events at the U.S. Capitol, his spokesman said. “In such circumstances, it is important that political leaders impress on their followers the need to refrain from violence, as well as to respect democratic processes and the rule of law,” U.N. spokesman Stephane Dujarric said in a statement.
NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg said on Twitter the “shocking scenes in Washington, D.C. The outcome of this democratic election must be respected.